Where to Start with Jane Austen

You've got less than 24 hours to enter for your chance to win some free music! Friday afternoon I'm coming with the random number generator and will announce the winner.

* * *

Awhile back, agent Nathan Bransford asked about our "gap books": in his words, "those books that everyone in the world has read and talks about all the time and look we are really meaning to read them but we're all very busy and there are a lot of books to read and no one could possibly be expected to read them all and why do I have to defend myself aha;sldkjf;aj"

(For me: Moby Dick, anything by Kafka, The Grapes of Wrath, Wuthering HeightsAnna KareninaThe Lord of the Flies... okay, hopefully I've embarrassed myself enough now. I don't like depressing stuff--does that show?)

I reference this owing to a question in yesterday's comments that I couldn't resist making into a blog post; the answer attempted to become a full-fledged essay as I typed in the combox. It's the best question I've been asked all week. Here it is: "For someone who has never read Jane Austen, where do you recommend starting?"

To George (who generally puts me to shame in the reading department): I'm so glad these are your gap books, because now I get to answer this question!

Pride and Prejudice, Persuasion, and Emma are--in my opinion--Austen's strongest works, and I recommend beginning with one of those three. Persuasion is probably the easiest and most relatable read for a modern American, although if said American has read other English classics, this might not matter. It meanders less, clearly values intelligence and integrity over rank, celebrates some degree of informality, and combines vivid portrayals of setting and character with a strong pensive mood.

On the other hand, Pride and Prejudice is the most popular; for several good reasons, I think. It includes lifelike characters who undergo excellent personal and relational growth, loads of the sly social mockery for which Austen is renowned, and brilliant voice and wit. It makes me laugh every time I read it, sometimes at things I'd never noticed before. I started with this one, and I've got no regrets over that.

Emma is a solid, well-plotted tale with exquisite character development and a true hero. It's also one of J. K. Rowling's favorite books; according to Rowling, "The best twist ever in literature is in Jane Austen's Emma. To me she is the target of perfection at which we shoot in vain."

My suggestion, then, for George and anyone else meeting Jane for the first time, is to pick whichever of those three appeals most to you from the outside and start there. Afterward, however, if you decide you like Austen, I highly recommend Mansfield Park and Sense and Sensibility as well. The former moves slower than the others, but has a very pure-minded heroine, and with its strong themes of faith and virtue, I find it a refreshing read. The latter, with sisters Elinor and Marianne Dashwood as personifications of the title attributes, is a fascinating character study and moving tale, despite rambling a little (it was Austen's first published novel, after all.)

I liked Northanger Abbey, but its heroine is on the childish side and therefore not quite as relatable.

The short epistolary story Lady Susan portrays a truly awful woman, which is interesting, but I found it less engaging than any of the others and have read it only once.

I hope that helps! If any of you reading this have suggestions of your own, I'd love to hear your thoughts. I can talk Austen like Harry Potter--the fandom just isn't as well organized. (Maybe I should write some Austen-themed songs? A little pianoforte accompaniment would do, if only I would give myself the trouble of practicing...)


  1. Thanks, Jenna. I'm glad you could make a blog post out of it. :)

    I just read the first chapter of Persuasion last night. Will try to get through it first.

    Oh, I would recommend reading Wuthering Heights. Sure, it's dark & somewhat depressing but it was still an excellent read & reading it also does help give insights into the character of Severus Snape. ;)

  2. I started with Sense and Sensibility. Loved it. But that's as far as I got, because I went on to discover Discworld next.

    P&P doesn't hold too much interest for me, frankly, and I'm bit annoyed by all the yahoo it's been getting in popular culture. Emma would probably be my next choice for an Austen, as I've seen a movie of it several times and am very comfortable in the story. Though now you've got in thinking about Persuasion.

    I read Moby Dick when I was twelve. Loved it, didn't understand it a bit. I also had a crush on Little Dorrit at about the same time, so go figure.

    I'd be interested to hear more of your fandom meditations on Miss Austen... :)

  3. No problem, George! I'll look forward to hearing what you think about Persuasion. I should jump back into the reading list on The Hog's Head soon--am getting way behind!

    Mr. Pond, I loved the Kate Beckinsale version of Emma, although as usual, I like the book best. The Emma Thompson/Kate Winslet/Alan Rickman/Hugh Grant version of Sense and Sensibility is stellar, in my opinion. I almost love that movie more than the book. Almost.

    Hmm. Maybe I'll have to do some writing about Austen, here or at The Hog's Head. I'll put some thought into it. Thanks for the suggestion!

  4. Ha! The Kate Beckinsale version was the one I grew up with. I have that movie near memorized. Emma Thompson's S&S is a classic.

    Though I must say, I've enjoyed Andrew Davies's newer adaptationsof those two very much. Also at the link I mentioned earlier. I must say, a completely different interpretation of S&S--surprisingly lyrical and haunting. Took the characters in intriguing dimensions for interpretation, too. Same for the new Emma.


All comments are currently moderated. Friendly comments are welcomed with fairy music, magic wishes, and possible unicorn sightings. Troll comments will be Transfigured into decent-looking rocks or Vanished. Spam comments will be shot down with blasters.