AI5 Top 7

American Idol. I watched it last night. I have no idea how Rory and Logan and Jess are doing.

Chris Daughtry, however, did fabulously. He outshined everyone else with the possible exception of Katharine McPhee.

Paris did a lovely job, but that song was just a little too mature for her in my opinion. She seems childlike, and heartbreak songs just don't seem to work with innocence.

Ace and Elliot can both go.

Kellie's funny when she messes up.

Rod Stewart is as good as Barry Manilow at helping people out. He's also fun to watch on stage. The only big secular concert I've ever been to was Def Leppard and Bryan Adams, so I didn't know that about Rod Stewart before now.

Good show. The Songbook was a great choice for a theme.


  1. I beg to disagree, Jenna.

    Paris and Ace can go.

    Kellie really screwed up, so she can go.

    Katherine and Chris are both solid. And I still love Taylor.

    Although I love Elliot's voice, I recognize that his stage presence is lacking...but I still have a soft spot for him. He can stay a few more weeks.

  2. Kellie is surviving on borrowed time. She'll be gone in the next 3-4 weeks, I'd wager.

    But then again, I thought Carrie Underwood was gone last year after she MANGLED "MacArthur Park", so what do I know? :-)


All comments are currently moderated. Friendly comments are welcomed with fairy music, magic wishes, and possible unicorn sightings. Troll comments will be Transfigured into decent-looking rocks or Vanished. Spam comments will be shot down with blasters.